Best Buy — Private Cards#

CONFIDENTIAL TO BEST BUY. Y1 cards distributed at start of Y1 solo prep. Y2 cards distributed at start of Y2 solo prep. Do not share contents with other participants unless the facilitator explicitly permits.

---

Y1 Cards#

Card Y1-A: The AI-PC Attach Rate Is Real — But the Margin Isn't#

Internal Q4 2025 category data, not yet shared with the Street: AI-PC sell-through is running about 30% ahead of plan, driven almost entirely by the Microsoft Copilot+ refresh and a sharper-than-expected uptick in small-business buyers walking into stores for guided purchases. Geek Squad setup attach on AI-PCs is the highest you have seen on any laptop category since the original Surface launch — around 1 in 3 units, vs. 1 in 8 on standard laptops.

The problem: vendor co-op marketing dollars on these SKUs are below historic norms because Microsoft, HP, and Dell are routing more spend to their own DTC channels. Unit economics on AI-PCs are around 200 bps below the comparable non-AI laptop a year ago. You are selling more units of a less profitable thing, and the merchant team is privately split on whether to lean harder in or quietly reprice the category.

What this signals: The thesis is working on volume; the vendor relationship is quietly degrading on margin. Y1 is a real fork: deepen the AI-PC bet (and accept margin compression) or push back on vendors now while you still have the demonstration leverage.

---

Card Y1-B: Bonfig's Private Read on Best Buy Health#

In a closed succession-planning session in March 2026, Jason Bonfig told the board that he believes Best Buy Health "should not have been built inside Best Buy" and that the 2025 write-down was probably not the last. He has not committed to a divestiture timeline, but he has asked the strategy team to model three scenarios: full sale of Lively to a senior-care operator, spin into a JV with a healthcare partner, or aggressive wind-down to a remote-monitoring-only footprint.

Barry, who remains CEO through October 31, has signaled she will not initiate a transaction in her final months — she does not want her legacy decision to be a second write-down. Any move waits for Bonfig.

What this signals: A divestiture or restructuring of Best Buy Health is a live Y1 or Y2 option. Acting in Y1 (before Bonfig formally takes the role) is unusual but not impossible if Barry can be persuaded. Waiting is the default — and arguably the safe play given the CEO transition.

---

Y2 Cards#

Card Y2-A: Apple Is Quietly Testing a Specialty-Retailer Bypass#

A senior Apple retail-partnerships executive — someone you have known for a decade — told you over dinner in January 2027 that Apple is piloting an expanded "Apple at Home" service in three metros: Genius-equivalent in-home setup, support, and trade-in, dispatched from Apple Stores and certified third-party technicians. Pricing is roughly competitive with Geek Squad Total Tech. The pilot does not yet include Best Buy's geography, but the internal Apple deck reportedly frames it as "reducing dependency on third-party specialty service for premium customers."

If this scales, it directly threatens the part of Geek Squad that subsidizes the rest of the model: high-margin in-home premium device support. Apple-related services revenue is around 20% of Geek Squad's in-home P&L. The Apple executive was clear this conversation was personal, not authorized.

What this signals: The vendor that anchors your most differentiated services franchise is exploring a path that disintermediates you. Your Y2 decision needs to grapple with whether to confront Apple (deepen exclusivity demands, threaten to deprioritize shop-in-shop), counter-build (reposition Geek Squad as device-agnostic), or accept and pivot to a lower-margin services mix.

---

Card Y2-B: The Marketplace Number That Hasn't Hit the Filings Yet#

Q4 2026 Best Buy Marketplace GMV came in materially ahead of plan — the highest single-quarter take-rate revenue contribution since launch. Two unexpected dynamics drove it: a wave of mid-tier Chinese-brand smart-home and audio sellers onboarding ahead of new tariff guidance, and a surprisingly strong attach of Best Buy Ads spending from those same sellers (they have no other US specialty surface that converts at this rate).

The finance team's draft FY27 plan now models Marketplace + Ads reaching roughly the contribution margin of a mid-sized store cluster by FY28. The risk: a meaningful share of the GMV is concentrated in categories where the merchant team competes directly — and the first internal complaints from category buyers about "Marketplace eating our lunch on accessories" landed in December.

What this signals: A small bet is quietly becoming a real one, but it is on a collision course with your first-party merchant business. Y2 is the window to decide whether to lean into Marketplace as a strategic growth engine (and manage the internal conflict openly) or cap it before it cannibalizes the core.

---

Document Version: Project Threshold V8.1 — Best Buy Private Cards Last Updated: May 2026